Display MoreIncorrect. Dragonking is far and away the best talisman.
At T8 Dragonking gives 9.6% fire dmg. At same tier the toy gives 327.6 mdmg. That is a very small boost for w/m.
-You forget also that W/M fire damage is increased by 36% (wl/m soul brand debuff)
-Mdmg increases with buffs yes but so does your flame attack :
I.E, wd/s + ch/p buffs are going to increase your flame attack more with wing of the dragonking than they would with annelia's toy.
Calculations are not perfect, but they are a good illustration as to why annelia's toy is NOT better than wing of the dragonking.
Mdmg increase without Toy :
Increases from 20.000 to 36.079 (increase of 16.079mdmg or an increase of 80%).
With toy :
20327.6 base mdmg.
Food: (20327.6+400)*1.12+400 = 23615
D/wd : (23615+165)*1.1+165 = 26323
Ch/P+Wd/S : 26323*1.2*1.16 = 36642 mdmg.
Increase from 20000 (base should be 20327, but let's give even more benefit to toy) to 36642 (increase of 16642 mdmg or an increase of 83%).
So as you can see, it only increases my mdmg by 3%. Still less than dragonking. Needs to be 6% or so to be better - 60% of my damage is from flame attack, and it increases flame attack by 10%. So 60%/10% for 6%.
I actually tested them before I chose the Toy, I didnt just pull 10% out of a hat.
Flame attack was seriously inconstant in damage. Most of the time it was less than electrical attack and once in a while higher than electrical attack. Also the toy increases damage of both flame and electrical attack.
AND... the toy turns you into a bear so I think that really settles the argument which is better!